Study Reveals Inaccuracies in Low-Cost Indoor Air Quality Monitors, Urges Rigorous Testing

September 23, 2024
Study Reveals Inaccuracies in Low-Cost Indoor Air Quality Monitors, Urges Rigorous Testing
  • The study's results indicated that the SenseAir S8 sensors exhibited a higher agreement with each other and with reference instruments than the Sensirion SCD sensors.

  • With most individuals spending approximately 90% of their time indoors, the measurement of indoor air quality (IAQ) is essential for health and wellbeing.

  • Poor IAQ has been linked to various health issues, including respiratory infections and heart disease, underscoring the importance of effective monitoring.

  • A recent study evaluated the performance of 87 low-cost IAQ monitors, focusing on their ability to measure key indicators such as total volatile organic compounds (tVOCs), particulate matter 2.5 (PM2.5), and carbon dioxide (CO2).

  • While CO2, temperature, and humidity sensors generally met manufacturer specifications, tVOC sensors exhibited significant accuracy issues, deviating by as much as 79% from reference measurements.

  • PM2.5 sensors showed consistency but had an error margin of ±27%, which is higher than the stated ±15% accuracy.

  • The study highlights the necessity for experimental evaluations of low-cost IAQ monitors before they are deployed in the field to ensure their reliability.

  • The research discussed various CO2 measurement methods, including estimated CO2 through tVOC sensors, NDIR sensors, and photo-acoustic sensors.

  • Both NDIR and photo-acoustic sensors utilize the gas absorption principle, measuring CO2 by detecting specific wavelengths of light absorbed by different gases.

  • Among the findings, NDIR sensors like the SenseAir S8 demonstrated better correlation with reference instruments outdoors compared to photo-acoustic sensors from Sensirion.

  • However, estimating CO2 through tVOC sensors, such as the Sensirion SGP30, is considered unreliable due to interference from other indoor organic components.

  • Despite their affordability and real-time data collection capabilities, low-cost IAQ monitors raise concerns regarding their accuracy and reliability compared to professional-grade instruments.

Summary based on 2 sources


Get a daily email with more Tech stories

More Stories