Supreme Court to Decide Fate of Trump's Transgender Military Ban Amid Legal Battles
April 24, 2025
Advocates for transgender rights have criticized the administration's actions, emphasizing that transgender service members have served honorably and met all military standards for nearly a decade.
Legal battles have ensued, with conflicting rulings from lower courts regarding the constitutionality of the ban, leading to the Supreme Court's involvement.
Sauer urged the Supreme Court to allow the ban to take effect immediately, except for eight service members who are legally challenging it.
In January 2025, President Trump issued an executive order asserting that transgender service members were unfit for duty due to their gender identity, which he labeled a 'false' expression.
The Trump administration has appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court to reinstate its ban on transgender individuals serving in the military, following lower court rulings that blocked the policy.
This ban seeks to reverse a policy established during Barack Obama's presidency that allowed transgender individuals to serve openly, although exceptions were made for those already transitioning.
Solicitor General John Sauer submitted a detailed brief appealing a district court's injunction from March 2025 that prevented the implementation of the ban.
The Supreme Court has historically upheld laws that discriminate based on sex in military contexts, which may influence its decision on this matter.
Despite the significant implications of the ban, the Constitution allows the government to make decisions perceived as self-harming, complicating legal challenges against it.
The Supreme Court has requested a response from the challengers of the ban by the following Thursday, indicating the urgency of the matter.
A federal judge previously ruled the executive order unconstitutional, describing it as 'soaked in animus,' thus blocking the ban's implementation.
Commander Emily Shilling, a veteran, argued that the ban would lead to the loss of trained personnel, posing a risk to national defense and military readiness.
Summary based on 20 sources
Get a daily email with more World News stories
Sources

The Guardian • Apr 24, 2025
Trump administration asks supreme court to reinstate ban on trans troops
Yahoo News • Apr 24, 2025
The Latest: Trump asks Supreme Court to allow ban on transgender troops to take effect for now
AP News • Apr 24, 2025
Trump asks Supreme Court to allow ban on transgender military members | AP News