On February 3, 2025, approximately 100,000 eggs valued at $40,000 were stolen from a distribution trailer belonging to Pete & Gerry's Organics in Greencastle, Pennsylvania.

The theft occurred around 8:40 p.m. and is classified as a felony under Pennsylvania law, prompting an investigation by the Pennsylvania State Police.

Authorities are currently seeking information from the public to assist in solving this unusual case, as no leads have emerged four days after the incident.

Pete & Gerry's Organics is cooperating with law enforcement and is committed to resolving the matter swiftly, taking the incident seriously.

Police are reviewing surveillance footage and following up with potential witnesses to identify the perpetrator of this unprecedented theft.

Trooper First Class Megan Frazer highlighted the uniqueness of this case, noting that she has never encountered a theft of this magnitude in her twelve-year career.

This theft coincides with a significant decline in U.S. egg production due to ongoing avian flu outbreaks, which have caused wholesale egg prices to rise sharply.

As of late 2024, the average price for a dozen eggs had reached $4.10, doubling since August 2023, with projections indicating a further 20% increase in 2025.

The egg shortage has led to panic buying among consumers, reminiscent of behaviors seen during the COVID-19 pandemic, further straining supply.

In response to the egg crisis, restaurants across the U.S. are adjusting their menus, with Waffle House implementing a temporary surcharge of 50 cents per egg.

The investigation into the theft is ongoing, and authorities encourage anyone with information to contact the Pennsylvania State Police Chambersburg.

The surge in egg prices has also led to increased demand for baby chicks and a rush on eggs at retailers, reflecting the broader impact of the current egg shortage.