Senate Passes Controversial Laken Riley Act; Sparks Debate Over Immigration, Civil Rights, and Costs
January 23, 2025On January 22, 2025, the Senate passed the Laken Riley Act, a controversial bill that mandates federal authorities to detain migrants accused of theft and violent crimes, aligning closely with President Trump's immigration policies.
The bill received bipartisan support in the House of Representatives, passing with a vote of 263 to 156, which included backing from approximately forty Democrats, highlighting divisions within the party on immigration matters.
Despite its passage, the bill has faced significant criticism for its projected cost of $83 billion over three years, with opponents warning that it could lead to chaos and civil rights violations.
Critics, including Representative Darren Soto, argue that the bill could violate the Fifth Amendment's due process rights by allowing deportation based solely on accusations without convictions.
Federal officials have cautioned that the law's implementation may face challenges due to insufficient federal resources, which could lead to the release of thousands of offenders.
Supporters of the bill claim it enhances public safety and serves as a deterrent against crime, while critics warn it threatens the rule of law and risks racial profiling.
Democratic Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has been vocal in her opposition, warning that the bill could undermine the rule of law and lead to unforeseen negative consequences.
The support for the bill among some Democrats, particularly those from battleground states, reflects pressure from constituents for stronger border security measures.
The Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency has indicated that the bill's implementation would require a significant increase in resources, estimating a cost of $26 billion for the first year alone.
Concerns have also been raised about the bill prioritizing the detention of individuals charged with minor offenses over serious criminals, potentially undermining public safety.
House Democratic Caucus Chair Pete Aguilar emphasized the need for comprehensive immigration reform that includes protections for vulnerable groups, contrasting with the punitive measures of the Laken Riley Act.
As the political landscape evolves, the implications of the Laken Riley Act on immigration law and visa issuance remain a topic of significant concern among lawmakers and advocacy groups.
Summary based on 37 sources
Get a daily email with more World News stories
Sources
The Guardian • Jan 20, 2025
US Senate passes migrant detention bill hours after Trump sworn inYahoo News • Jan 20, 2025
US Senate passes migrant detention bill hours after Trump sworn inNBC News • Jan 20, 2025
Senate passes Laken Riley Act aimed at cracking down on illegal immigration