Judge Halts Trump Campaign's Use of 'Hold On, I’m Coming' Amid Hayes Estate Lawsuit
September 3, 2024A U.S. District Court judge has issued a temporary injunction preventing the Trump campaign from using the song 'Hold On, I’m Coming,' following a lawsuit from the estate of Isaac Hayes.
The Hayes estate claims that the Trump campaign has used the song without proper licensing, alleging it has been played nearly 30 times since a license termination.
James Walker, attorney for the Hayes estate, expressed confidence in the case's success, noting that Trump has faced multiple complaints from artists regarding unauthorized music use.
Trump's legal team contends they obtained permission through a BMI license, a claim disputed by the Hayes estate.
The song has been frequently used at Trump rallies, including as exit music during significant events like the Republican National Convention.
Isaac Hayes III, the son of the late musician, emphasized the importance of protecting his father's legacy and the rights to the music, which has recently returned to the family after decades.
While the judge's ruling does not require the removal of existing videos featuring the song, the Hayes estate is demanding $3 million in licensing fees for its repeated use.
The case will move forward to an evidentiary process and trial, where further infringement claims will be evaluated.
The Hayes estate's lawyer indicated they are working to have existing videos removed as the case progresses.
Isaac Hayes III expressed satisfaction with the court's decision, hoping it encourages other artists to protect their rights against unauthorized use.
Trump's representatives confirmed they would comply with the injunction and have already ceased using the song at campaign events.
Legal actions by musicians against political figures often take a long time to resolve, with limited success, highlighting the ongoing struggle for artists' rights.
Summary based on 11 sources
Get a daily email with more US News stories
Sources
The New York Times • Sep 3, 2024
Trump Ordered to Stop Using Isaac Hayes’s ‘Hold On, I’m Coming’ at RalliesThe Guardian • Sep 3, 2024
Trump ordered by judge to stop playing Isaac Hayes song at campaign ralliesBBC News • Sep 4, 2024
Donald Trump ordered to stop using Isaac Hayes' music at his rallies