'All In: Comedy About Love' is currently running at the Hudson Theatre and will continue until mid-February 2024, with ticket prices soaring up to $800.

The show features a lineup of 14 celebrities, including notable names like John Mulaney, Renée Elise Goldsberry, Richard Kind, and Fred Armisen, who perform seated with binders in hand.

While there are moments of scattered laughter, the humor often relies on repetitive jokes and anachronisms, which ultimately diminish its comedic impact.

Despite its title suggesting a focus on romance, the review indicates that the show misleads audiences, presenting a series of disjointed comedic bits instead.

Adapted from humorist Simon Rich's short stories, the performance has been criticized for resembling a simple staged reading rather than a fully realized theatrical production.

Director Alex Timbers attempts to enhance the experience with original music and a coffee house-style set, but the execution falls short of what is expected from a Broadway show.

The initial performances are described as quirky and self-satisfied, yet they lack a coherent comedic structure, leaving audiences wanting more.