Second U.S. Execution Using Nitrogen Gas Sparks Controversy Over Method's Humanity and Effectiveness

September 26, 2024
Second U.S. Execution Using Nitrogen Gas Sparks Controversy Over Method's Humanity and Effectiveness
  • In the U.S., the death penalty has been abolished in 23 states, while six others are under a moratorium on executions, reflecting a broader decline in support for capital punishment.

  • Miller's execution follows a previous attempt in September 2022 that was aborted due to difficulties in establishing intravenous access for lethal injection.

  • Convicted in 2000 for a 1999 workplace shooting spree that resulted in the deaths of three men, Miller's case has drawn significant attention.

  • Alan Eugene Miller, a 59-year-old man from Alabama, was executed using nitrogen gas, marking the second instance of this method being used in the U.S.

  • Despite initially challenging the nitrogen gas method, Miller settled with the state last month, agreeing to proceed with the execution under Alabama's alternative to lethal injection.

  • Alabama became the first state to execute a prisoner using nitrogen hypoxia in January 2023, raising concerns about the method's humanity and effectiveness.

  • Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall has defended nitrogen hypoxia as 'swift, painless and humane,' despite eyewitness accounts of distress during the first execution.

  • Death penalty opponents are urging Governor Kay Ivey to halt Miller's execution, citing issues that arose during the execution of Kenneth Smith.

  • Witnesses reported that Miller exhibited physical distress during the execution process, including shaking and gasping.

  • In his final words, Miller claimed, 'I didn't do anything to be in here,' highlighting the ongoing controversy surrounding his conviction.

  • The discussion around execution methods continues to evolve, with increasing scrutiny on the implications of nitrogen hypoxia and its potential for causing suffering.

  • Human rights advocates have criticized nitrogen hypoxia as a form of 'human experimentation,' arguing that no execution method can truly be deemed humane.

Summary based on 9 sources


Get a daily email with more World News stories

More Stories