Judge Laura Bruniard has indicated that Nores may be held responsible for negligent homicide, emphasizing that he should have sought medical help for Payne.

Prosecutors have pointed out that hotel staff recognized Payne's vulnerable condition but failed to ensure his safety until medical assistance could arrive.

Five individuals have been charged in connection with the death of Liam Payne, the former One Direction star, who tragically fell from a third-floor balcony at the CasaSur Palermo Hotel in Argentina on October 16, 2024.

Witnesses reported that shortly before his fall, Payne displayed erratic behavior, including shouting in the hotel lobby and showing signs of distress.

Payne's funeral service in London drew attendance from his former bandmates, who expressed their sorrow and reflected on their time together.

Toxicology tests revealed that Payne had alcohol, cocaine, and a prescription antidepressant in his system at the time of his death.

Among those charged are a hotel employee and a waiter, both of whom have been ordered to preventive prison for allegedly supplying drugs to Payne.

The court is set to determine whether the actions of Roger Nores, who left Payne alone for 40 minutes prior to the incident, constitute negligence.

In his defense, Nores filed a lengthy document asserting that he was not responsible for Payne's well-being, claiming he left him in a seemingly fine state to greet fans.

Leading up to his death, Payne faced significant personal challenges, including legal issues with his ex-fiancée and a declining music career.

The judge noted that bringing Payne to his hotel room in his intoxicated state posed a significant risk, particularly given the presence of a balcony.

The legal proceedings surrounding Payne's death have sparked discussions about the impact of his fame on the investigation and the scrutiny involved.