Study: Physicians Show Limited Diagnostic Improvement Using ChatGPT-4, Highlighting AI Training Needs
November 18, 2024The study indicated that simply having access to large language models like ChatGPT does not inherently enhance physicians' diagnostic reasoning skills.
Dr. Rodman suggested that AI should serve as 'doctor extenders,' providing valuable second opinions to enhance diagnostic accuracy.
A recent study led by Dr. Adam Rodman, an internal medicine expert at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, evaluated the impact of ChatGPT-4 on physicians' diagnostic capabilities.
The study involved 50 licensed physicians to determine whether using ChatGPT could enhance their ability to diagnose medical conditions.
Results revealed that while ChatGPT-4 achieved an impressive average score of 90% in diagnosing medical conditions, physicians using the chatbot scored an average of 76%, and those without it scored 74%.
Despite these findings, physicians using ChatGPT-4 alongside traditional resources showed only a slight improvement over those without access to the chatbot.
It also highlighted a significant gap in physicians' understanding of how to effectively utilize AI tools, leading to missed opportunities in leveraging chatbots for complex diagnostic challenges.
This is particularly concerning as many healthcare systems now provide HIPAA-compliant chatbots for clinical use, often without adequate training for physicians.
Many doctors exhibited strong convictions about their own diagnoses, sometimes disregarding potentially better suggestions from ChatGPT.
These results were consistent across various subgroups of doctors, indicating a universal challenge in integrating AI into medical practice.
Ultimately, the findings suggest that while AI has potential, its effectiveness is contingent on proper training and integration into clinical workflows.
The implications of this study are crucial as the healthcare industry increasingly adopts AI technologies without ensuring that physicians are adequately prepared to use them.
Summary based on 4 sources
Get a daily email with more AI stories
Sources
Slashdot • Nov 18, 2024
ChatGPT-4 Beat Doctors at Diagnosing Illness, Study Finds - SlashdotFudzilla • Nov 18, 2024
ChatGPT defeats the quacksFudzilla • Nov 18, 2024
ChatGPT defeats the quacksOODAloop • Nov 18, 2024
A.I. Chatbots Defeated Doctors at Diagnosing Illness