The New Jersey Devils showed promise but struggled with injuries, particularly to Jack Hughes, resulting in a C grade for the season.

The 2024-25 NHL regular season concluded on April 17, 2025, with all 16 playoff teams determined and report cards issued for each franchise.

The Winnipeg Jets achieved a historic milestone by clinching the Presidents' Trophy for the first time in franchise history, finishing the season with an impressive record of 56-22-4 and earning an A+ grade.

The New York Islanders faced internal turmoil and missed the playoffs, earning a D grade for their lack of direction.

The Athletic's NHL staff assigned final grades to all 32 teams, reflecting on each team's performance and expectations throughout the season.

The Los Angeles Kings also excelled, tying their franchise record with 48 wins and 105 points, which earned them an A grade after surpassing expectations following three consecutive playoff exits.

The Minnesota Wild made the playoffs despite injuries and salary cap issues, receiving a B grade for their resilience.

In contrast, the Boston Bruins faced significant struggles, finishing with one of the league's worst records due to injuries and roster flaws, earning a D grade.

The Columbus Blue Jackets surprised many with their competitive play, showcasing young talent and receiving an A- grade despite missing the playoffs.

The Montreal Canadiens returned to the playoffs with a young core and impactful additions, earning an A grade for their progress.

On the lower end of the spectrum, the Nashville Predators and Vancouver Canucks both received Fs, marking highly disappointing seasons with significant roster and performance issues.

The Dallas Stars were graded A- after finishing with 50 wins and making key roster additions despite losing key players to injuries during the season.