Charlotte FC coach Dean Smith also criticized the lack of aggregate scoring, suggesting it allows teams to progress despite poor overall performances.

In contrast, previous playoff formats that utilized aggregate scoring over two games were seen by some as providing a more balanced competition.

This playoff structure is projected to increase the total number of matches, with teams potentially playing between 25 and 33 postseason games, a significant rise from just 13 matches in 2022.

The 2024 MLS playoffs are currently underway, with the final first-round games taking place over the weekend.

As of today, four teams have already advanced to the conference semifinals, while four first-round games are still pending to determine the remaining matchups.

Among those advancing are the Galaxy and Minnesota United, who will face off in the conference semifinals on November 23, following a long break due to a FIFA international window.

This year's playoff format, introduced in 2023, features a wild-card round and a best-of-three series for the first round, with penalty kicks used to resolve any draws.

The wild-card matches have garnered positive reactions, highlighted by the Vancouver Whitecaps' victory over Portland and Atlanta United's success in a penalty shootout against Montreal.

However, the new first-round format has faced criticism from players and coaches, who find it lengthy and overly complex.

Despite the dissatisfaction, MLS is expected to maintain this playoff structure for the time being, as teams vie for the MLS Cup Final scheduled for December 7.

LAFC captain Aaron Long expressed a preference for a simpler home-and-away or single-game format instead of the current best-of-three setup.

Seattle Sounders goalkeeper Stefan Frei echoed these concerns, questioning the fairness of advancing after a significant loss but winning on penalties.