The selection of attacking players for the Best XI included high-profile talents like Messi, Cucho Hernandez, and Benteke, showcasing a diverse array of skills and performances.

The 2024 MLS Best XI has been officially announced in a 3-4-2-1 formation, featuring standout players such as Krisjian Kahlina in goal, Steven Moreira in defense, and forwards Lionel Messi and Christian Benteke.

The guiding principle behind the Best XI vote is to encapsulate the narrative of the 2024 MLS regular season, reflecting both individual excellence and team dynamics.

Additionally, the unofficial Third XI employs a 4-3-3 formation, featuring players like Brad Stuver and Emeka Eneli, emphasizing strong defensive and midfield performances.

There is a belief that MLS should expand the Best XI to include a Second and Third XI, which would better reflect the season's narrative and recognize a broader range of players.

Emeka Eneli was recognized as the best defensive midfielder, leading the league in recoveries and playing a crucial role in his team's achievements.

Krisjian Kahlina earned the title of Goalkeeper of the Year, while Steven Moreira was named Defender of the Year, and Lionel Messi took home the MVP award, highlighting their exceptional contributions to the season.

The selection process for the Best XI is subjective and contextual, allowing for flexibility in the criteria applied to various players throughout the season.

Criteria for the Best XI decisions include the desire to resemble a real-life starting XI and the significant impact of individual performances on overall team success.

Micael from Houston Dynamo was highlighted for his exceptional performance as a defender, having made a significant leap from the second team.

The unofficial Second XI features a 4-3-3 formation that includes players like Matt Freese in goal, Federico Bernardeschi, and Luis Suárez, showcasing additional talent from the season.