Terry Francona's Reds Managerial Debut Marred by Ninth-Inning Collapse, Gibaut's Closer Role Questioned
March 28, 2025
Returning to manage after a year off, Francona noted that every day at the ballpark is special, contrasting this year's experience with last year, which he spent away from baseball.
Despite the loss, Jeimer Candelario had a strong performance, contributing two hits and three RBIs, while the Reds' pitching staff recorded 16 strikeouts, the second-highest for an Opening Day.
Patrick Bailey's hit tied the game, and Wilmer Flores hit a home run, putting the Giants ahead, leading to immediate second-guessing of Francona's decision to use Gibaut as closer.
Francona downplayed the significance of the Opening Day result, noting that it is not indicative of the season's trajectory and emphasizing the importance of resilience.
Terry Francona debuted as the manager of the Cincinnati Reds on March 27, 2025, but faced a tough start with a 6-4 loss to the San Francisco Giants.
Francona expressed the importance of not letting the loss affect the team's morale and emphasized the need to approach the season with resilience.
The Reds led 3-2 entering the ninth inning but allowed four runs, with Ian Gibaut pitching despite a history of struggling in save situations.
Francona's decision to use Ian Gibaut as closer raised eyebrows, especially given Gibaut's history of 10 blown saves and only four career saves.
Despite the loss, Reds pitcher Hunter Greene defended Gibaut, emphasizing team support and confidence in his abilities.
Francona began the day with an emergency dental visit to fix a broken veneer, humorously stating he didn't want to look unkempt on Opening Day.
Cincinnati's closer situation is unstable, with Alexis Díaz on the injured list due to hamstring issues.
Starting pitcher Hunter Greene struck out eight batters in five innings and publicly supported Gibaut after the game, reinforcing team solidarity despite the loss.
Summary based on 3 sources
Get a daily email with more MLB stories
Sources

AP News • Mar 28, 2025
Terry Francona has rough opening day in debut as Reds manager
ESPN • Mar 28, 2025
Ninth-inning collapse for Reds caps Francona's rough Opening Day - ESPN
Spectrum News 1 Ohio • Mar 28, 2025
Terry Francona has rough opening day in debut as Reds manager