MLB Introduces Hybrid Umpiring: Human Calls with Tech-Supported Challenges in Triple-A

November 21, 2024
MLB Introduces Hybrid Umpiring: Human Calls with Tech-Supported Challenges in Triple-A
  • The ABS challenge system represents a compromise between human judgment and full automation, potentially paving the way for future advancements in umpiring.

  • Currently, the ABS defines strikes based on the ball's midpoint crossing the plate, with the top of the strike zone set at 53.5% of a batter's height.

  • In 2024, Major League Baseball (MLB) implemented an all-challenge system in Triple-A, transitioning from an initial phase where robot umpires were used exclusively.

  • Under this new system, human umpires will continue to call balls and strikes, while teams are allowed a limited number of challenges to appeal on-field decisions.

  • Teams retain their challenges if successful, mirroring the video review rules used in the major leagues.

  • The automated ball-strike (ABS) technology, which utilizes Hawk-Eye cameras to monitor pitch locations relative to the strike zone, has been in use in Triple-A since 2022.

  • This technology enhances accuracy in decision-making, although it has faced scrutiny as not every pitch that is a strike appears so visually to players and fans.

  • Last year, MLB reported a 47% success rate for teams using the challenge system in Triple-A games.

  • Each team in Triple-A is permitted two to three challenges per game, depending on the league, with successful challenges allowing teams to retain their attempts.

  • Looking ahead, MLB plans to test robot umpires through the ABS challenge system during Spring training in 2025, with an eye toward implementation in the 2026 regular season.

  • Commissioner Rob Manfred emphasized that player experience will be crucial in determining the timeline for the system's implementation.

  • The transition from robot umpires being a radical idea to a likely reality reflects the growing acceptance of technology in the game, as many current players have prior experience with the system.

Summary based on 19 sources


Get a daily email with more MLB stories

More Stories