Controversial Book on Infamous Child Murders Sparks Legal and Ethical Debate in Spain

March 28, 2025
Controversial Book on Infamous Child Murders Sparks Legal and Ethical Debate in Spain
  • Ortiz's legal complaint has shifted from Córdoba to Barcelona, where the publisher Anagrama is located, with her lawyer asserting that the media coverage surrounding the book has caused her additional suffering.

  • In response to the situation, a public prosecutor in Barcelona called for a temporary suspension of the book's publication, but a judge ruled that it should proceed, highlighting the importance of freedom of speech.

  • The controversy surrounding the potential publication of 'El odio' by Luisgé Martín has ignited significant debate in Spain, as the book is based on the confession of José Bretón, who infamously murdered his two children in 2011.

  • This case raises critical questions about the balance between creative freedom and the rights of victims and their families, particularly in the realm of true crime narratives.

  • Despite the book's scheduled release, numerous bookstores have chosen not to stock 'El odio' on ethical grounds, citing the potential harm it could inflict on Ortiz.

  • In an open letter, Ortiz warned that the publication of the book threatens to re-victimize those already affected by Bretón's heinous crimes.

  • The murders committed by Bretón are among the most horrific cases of violence against minors in Spain's history, which has sparked widespread outrage and legal discussions.

  • Martín, the author, contends that 'El odio' does not give Bretón a voice but rather critiques his actions and delves into the depths of his depravity.

  • Political parties in Spain have approached the issue of censorship cautiously, with the far-right Vox party being the exception, advocating for stricter measures against criminals like Bretón.

  • A review of the book described it as 'valuable and hypnotic literature,' although it criticized the lack of communication with Ortiz prior to its publication.

  • Bretón, who drugged his six-year-old daughter and two-year-old son before burning their bodies, is currently serving a 25-year prison sentence for his crimes.

  • Ruth Ortiz, the mother of the victims, is actively seeking to prevent the book's release, arguing that it disrespects the memory of her children and infringes on the rights of victims.

Summary based on 2 sources


Get a daily email with more Literature stories

More Stories