Montgomery County Reverses Controversial Reclassification of Indigenous History Book Amid Outcry

October 21, 2024
Montgomery County Reverses Controversial Reclassification of Indigenous History Book Amid Outcry
  • Montgomery County, Texas, faced significant backlash after it reclassified Linda Coombs' nonfiction book 'Colonization and the Wampanoag Story' as fiction in local libraries.

  • In response to the outcry, Montgomery County reversed its decision and reinstated the book's classification as nonfiction.

  • The reclassification drew condemnation from anti-censorship advocates and Penguin Random House, who argued it undermines freedom of expression.

  • Debbie Reese, founder of American Indians in Children’s Literature, highlighted the book's importance for both Native and non-Native children in understanding history.

  • The controversy surrounding the reclassification became public in mid-October, following records requests by free speech advocates.

  • PEN America and various advocacy groups criticized the reclassification as a threat to freedom of expression and a dismissal of Indigenous perspectives.

  • The Texas Freedom to Read Project has collected over 34,000 signatures on a petition demanding the book's reinstatement in the juvenile nonfiction section.

  • Kasey Meehan from PEN America stated that restricting access to the book limits young readers' understanding of America's true history.

  • The reclassification was influenced by rightwing activists and followed a challenge from a local resident, leading to the creation of a citizen review committee.

  • However, the committee's meetings were kept secret, and librarians were excluded from discussions about the book's classification.

  • Texas ranks second in the nation for book bans, with over 1,500 titles removed between 2021 and 2023, highlighting a troubling trend in censorship.

  • Despite Montgomery County's decision, major libraries, including the Houston Public Library and the Library of Congress, continue to classify Coombs' book as nonfiction.

Summary based on 3 sources


Get a daily email with more US News stories

More Stories