Phil Mickelson: Risk-Taker or Underachiever? A Legacy of Thrills and Controversy

March 28, 2025
Phil Mickelson: Risk-Taker or Underachiever? A Legacy of Thrills and Controversy
  • Despite his numerous accomplishments, Phil Mickelson is often perceived as an underachiever in golf, primarily due to his tendency to take risks that have cost him major victories.

  • His playing style, characterized by a willingness to take risks, has resulted in both thrilling successes and disappointing failures, making him an exciting player to watch.

  • Mickelson has secured six major championships, the most in the 21st century after Tiger Woods, and boasts a total of 45 wins, tying him for eighth-most with Walter Hagen.

  • He redeemed himself later in his career by winning the 2013 British Open and the 2021 PGA Championship, where he made history as the oldest major winner at 50 years old.

  • This achievement makes him the only player to win a professional major after turning 50.

  • However, his decision to join LIV Golf in 2022 has sparked debate about his legacy, with some critics viewing it as a tarnish on his career due to his controversial remarks about the tour's backers.

  • Opinions about Mickelson's legacy remain divided; while some see his career as disappointing due to missed opportunities, others appreciate his exciting play and contributions to the sport.

  • In a forthcoming book titled "The Golf 100," veteran golf writer Michael Arkush ranks Mickelson 13th among the greatest golfers of all time, set to be published on April 1, 2025.

  • Mickelson's early career was marked by significant success, including winning the Junior World Golf Championship at age 10 and the U.S. Amateur in 1990, but he initially struggled in majors, with only three top 10 finishes in his first 10 attempts.

  • He finally broke through with his first major win at the 2004 Masters at age 33, although he continued to face challenges in subsequent tournaments, such as a notable three-putt at the 2004 Open at Shinnecock.

  • A notable example of his risky play occurred at the 2006 U.S. Open at Winged Foot, where a critical mistake on the final hole cost him a chance at victory.

Summary based on 1 source


Get a daily email with more Golf stories

More Stories