Acclaimed filmmaker Imtiaz Ali sparked controversy during his speech at the International Film Festival of India (IFFI) on November 23, 2024, by claiming that the Mumbai film industry is a safe space for women.

In his remarks, Ali cited the experiences of Bollywood actors Alia Bhatt and Kareena Kapoor, suggesting their comfort on set as evidence of safety in the industry.

He also shared an anecdote about Kareena Kapoor's positive experience during the filming of 'Jab We Met' and described an incident where he intervened to protect Alia Bhatt's privacy while filming 'Highway'.

Filmmaker Vinita Nanda expressed her shock at Ali's comments, arguing that they do not reflect the reality faced by many women in the industry.

Nanda criticized Ali for his assertion, emphasizing that privileged individuals like Kapoor do not represent the broader experiences of women in film.

She pointed out on Instagram that while privileged women may feel safe, the existence of issues like the casting couch remains a harsh reality.

Nanda condemned Ali for discussing women's experiences without having lived them, suggesting that his comments serve to obscure the truth about serious issues in the industry.

She urged men like Ali to refrain from speaking on topics they have not personally experienced, highlighting the need for genuine change regarding women's safety and rights.

Nanda also questioned why the IFFI chose Ali to speak on women's issues, suggesting it might be an attempt to obscure the truth about women's experiences in the industry.

This exchange underscores ongoing debates about gender safety and privilege within the film industry, illustrating a significant divide in perspectives.

Following the backlash from his comments, Ali clarified on Instagram that there was no misconduct on the set of 'Highway' and praised his crew as exemplary.